Decision Making at the Fire - Water Nexus: Reflections on our Masters of the Environment (MENV) Capstone Project

November 18, 2026

Written by Daisy Ranney Smith

As the end of the year approaches, so does the conclusion of the University of Colorado Boulder’s Master of the Environment capstone season. Over the past nine months, myself and a team of two other graduate students have been researching private landowner and boundary organization decision-making at the fire-water nexus. For this social science-based project we partnered with Aspen Global Change Institute (AGCI), a nonprofit based in Basalt, Colorado, whose mission is to advance global change science and solutions.  


Our work began in February when we met with our partners and faculty advisor to refine our scope of work and establish the project’s goals. Together, we identified two primary deliverables. 


Colorado River Science Wiki – A Series of Case Studies  


Our first deliverable focused on developing content for an interactive GIS map informed by wildfire case studies throughout the Colorado River Basin and published on the Colorado River Science Wiki page. These case studies examined the effects of wildfire on hydrological processes and functions throughout the Colorado River Basin and were broken down by, background information, primary impacts, and secondary impacts to provide a detailed overview of wildfires that burned significant acreage within the basin. Although the Colorado River Science Wiki site doesn’t draw a significant amount of human engagement, AI is one of its primary users. By contributing accurate, accessible, and well-organized information through these case studies and the accompanying interactive map, we hope to improve the quality and reach of information about wildfire impacts on water resources in the Colorado River Basin.  


Our team has completed the case studies and development of the interactive map is underway.  


Understanding Decision Making at the Fire–Water Nexus 


Our second but most substantial deliverable was a qualitative review of private landowners' decision making. The goals of this synthesis are to identify the needs and knowledge gaps of private-sector decisionmakers, improve the relevance and accessibility of fire–water science, and inform future research and management strategies across the Western United States.  


During the first few months of our project, we reviewed existing literature and identified a significant gap in research surrounding private land management in the context of increasing wildfire risk and water resources. Our next step was to obtain Institutional Review Board (IRB) approval to conduct group and individual interviews with stakeholders across Colorado and New Mexico in the next phase of the project over the summer.  


Through these conversations, we sought to better understand how landowners and users access and apply information about wildfire, the risks and challenges they face as wildfire impacts increase, and how existing policies and regulations support or hinder effective land and water management.


 Some sample interview questions included:  

  • What are the most consequential decisions you make that impact water and are influenced by wildfire? 
  • What types of information or data do you currently rely on to understand fire impacts on water resources?  And how do you use it (for planning, communication, research?) 
  • At what points in the wildfire lifecycle (pre-fire, during fire, immediate post-fire, long-term recovery) do water-related decisions matter most to you? 
  • How do you currently interact with researchers/managers/owners around fire and water issues? 

What We Heard and Key Findings 


Several key themes emerged from our conversations over the summer. Our biggest and most prolific finding is that landowners are not looking for a silver bullet technical solution, but rather more effective science communication and community engagement with the academic and research community.  


Although researchers conduct valuable work on wildfire and water resources, participants described challenges in accessing information that is relevant, understandable, and applicable to their specific land management needs.   


We also heard concerns about the persistence of "parachute science," where researchers enter communities to collect information or conduct research without establishing lasting relationships, or meaningfully involving local stakeholders, not to mention ever sharing the findings and data back with the people and communities who contributed.  


One landowner shared a particularly interesting example involving a colleague who had been collecting data and sending it to a local university for over 20 years. Yet, when they went to retrieve that data, they were told that it had been misplaced, and the professor leading the project had retired. This disconnect can create barriers to trust, discourage future collaboration, and limit the functional application of research. 


Another recurring challenge was the lack of a centralized, accessible source for information related to wildfire, water, and land management. Landowners often must navigate multiple agencies, organizations, websites, and research publications to find information relevant to their decision-making process. When we asked landowners where they got the information from, we coded 10 different categories, ranging from universities to social media. In a field where time is of essence, this lack of a centralized source forces landowners to dedicate time that they might not choose to invest in research efforts. 


Many of our participants also highlighted the difficulty of applying research findings across different landscapes and ecosystems. The complexity and variability of Western landscapes means that management recommendations developed in one location may not translate directly to another. These findings reinforce the importance of moving beyond one-size-fits-all approaches and creating opportunities for researchers and landowners to work together through site visits, local knowledge exchange, and ongoing communication. 

So, How Do We Bridge This Gap? 

 

Addressing these challenges requires more than simply producing additional research or recognizing a gap in knowledge. These issues require ongoing investments in the relationships and communication methods that connect researchers, landowners, and communities.  


Several opportunities emerged through our research. These include increasing funding for community and stakeholder engagement, particularly in rural areas; conducting more site visits to understand local perspectives and management practices; and establishing systems that support consistent, two-way communication between researchers and landowners. 


The Forest Stewards Guild’s work with the Greater Santa Fe Fireshed Coalition provides an example of how these kinds of recommendations can be put into practice. For more than a decade, the Guild has helped connect researchers with interested members of the public across the Fireshed landscape. One ongoing outcome of this collaboration is a publicly accessible collection of curated, open-source research and resources focused on locally driven and relevant science.  


The Guild also helped plan and convene the  Common Ground Workshop in 2019, which brought fire scientists, decisionmakers, and community members together to encourage dialogue and share understanding around wildfire and fire ecology. These efforts demonstrate the importance of making locally relevant science accessible while creating opportunities for meaningful community conversations and preventing the spread of misinformation. 


We recognize that many of these recommendations depend heavily on funding availability. Some potential opportunities include; expanding public and private funding sources, supporting regional research collaborations, and exploring innovative funding mechanisms that prioritize applied science and community engagement.      


In Colorado, Proposition 137(Direct Sporting Goods Sales Tax Revenue for Conservation), which recently passed in the fall election, represents one example of a broader effort to direct funding toward land and water conservation, watershed restoration, and wildfire mitigation. Additionally, ongoing climate accountability litigation, including the lawsuit brought by Boulder County and the City of Boulder against Suncor Energy and ExxonMobil, highlights the growing costs of climate-related impacts on local communities. 


Improving Access and Where We Can Go from Here  


Improving access to existing research and creating stronger connections between science and practice are important next steps. The Colorado River Science Wiki is an example. An online resource like this aims to bring together scientific research, technical information, and datasets relevant to Colorado River Basin management. Resources like the Wiki demonstrate the value of centralized information platforms that make research easier to find and use, even if AI is one of its primary users.   


Building on these efforts, a broader research team with the Aspen Global Change Institute and the Western Fire and Forest Resilience Collaborative (WFFRC) is continuing to explore opportunities, with the public sector on these perspectives to improve the accessibility and application of fire–water science and land management. Our team's research will eventually contribute to this broader initiative, bringing forward perspectives from both private landowners and public-sector decisionmakers. Future work could focus on identifying ways to connect landowners with relevant research, strengthening regional information-sharing networks, and developing a practical guide to existing science, tools, and resources for landowners and rural communities. 


A Closing Note 


Our team would like to thank our partners at AGCI; especially Kelli Archie, Tanya Petach, and Julie Vano; our faculty advisor Gregor MacGregor; as well as all those who took part in our interviews or assisted in the outreach process.  


This research process has produced meaningful findings and valuable deliverables while also giving our team the opportunity to apply our skills, develop new skills, and grow as young professionals in the environmental sector. Along the way, we presented our work twice to the Masters of the Environment (MENV) community and also shared our research at the Mountain Clim Research Conference at the Rocky Mountain Biological Laboratory in Gothic, Colorado. 


Overall, this project has been a rewarding, challenging, and incredibly valuable experience. As we prepare to conclude our capstone work this December, we are grateful for the opportunity to contribute to an important area of research and to work alongside the individuals and organizations committed to advancing wildfire resilience and water resource management across the West.  


Daisy's student research team held a webinar with the Guild to present their capstone project on 11/19. Visit our YouTube page to watch the recording! 

Bio: When she isn't working as a communications contractor for the Guild, Daisy is busy pursuing her master's degree in Environmental Policy at the University of Colorado Boulder. She'll graduate in May 2027 and previously earned her B.A. in Journalism and Media Communications from Colorado State University in December 2024. A few of Daisy’s goals post-graduation, include communicating science in a way that is easily understood and received by a general audience, applying and researching policies to the environment’s advantage, and spending more time in the mountains. 

Recent Posts

November 18, 2026
Written by Ami Kane, Chief Development Officer
November 16, 2026
Written by Michael Lynch, Great Lakes Director
November 13, 2026
The Guild has partnered with U.S Fish and Wildlife Service and hired forestry technician at the Moosehorn National Wildlife Refuge in Maine. Below, read about some of what two of these technicians have learned and accomplished this season.
October 13, 2026
Written by Nick Alpeza
October 9, 2026
The Paper Birch: A Central Character in the Story of Ecological Succession
October 1, 2026
Written by Dave Wager, forest ecologist
September 17, 2026
Written by Eytan Krasilovsky 
September 14, 2026
Written by Mackenzie Alexander and Eytan Krasilovsky
Show More